Saturday, July 07, 2007

Down With Adaptation



So I've been meaning to write about this for a while but Valerie and I went and saw the worst frickin play EVER. Who was it written by? Oh, Shakespeare. El Bardo.

New York, New York. City of five hundred playhouses. Sure, it all can't be good. In fact, most isn't. Even the big stuff has a whole lot of suck in it. But there's genius, real genius in some of these small playhouses, in some of these new plays. If I had more time, money, inclination, need, I would go and seek them out. But as it were Val and I see what we can and try to hit the good ones. We ended up seeing two Shakespeare plays in June. One was brilliant. The other? Excrement.

Shakespeare in the Park is a free show that plays in Central Park June through August. High quality, great stuff.

GRADES
Romeo and Juliet in Central Park: A
Twelfth Night in Back Room: F-

Besides mega budget, what was the difference? Well, the first one stayed true to the play. No wild interpretations, just letting the words the carry the actors. Actors and words, actors and words! That's all you need.

The second one? Some crap filled modern adaptation. Oh, what did it start the play off with? None other than "Funk Soul Brother" by Fat Boy Slim. The actors all played multiple characters which is great, fine, a lovely thing. Shakespeare intended that way. But instead of letting Shakespeare tell the jokes, the actors thought that nothing is funnier than...accents! Yes, multiple confusing geographically distant accents. And besides a lot of suck acting, including a girl that must have had a stroke in her face because it never changed expression, they kept at the idiotic interpretation for two hours at least. Valerie and I started planning a murder/suicide. Unfortunately, we couldn't leave because someone she knew was in it. Thankfully, he was the best thing in it. Which is comparing horse crap to pig crap.

STOP THE SHAKESPEAREAN ADAPTATIONS! A time period change? Great. But why, why does everyone need to reinvent the purported greatest writer ever? Maybe it makes me mad because no one adapts anything else!

No one thinks, "Do you know what The Crucible needs? To be done on Glo Paint swings!"
Or "Sure, Streetcar Named Desire is great but wouldn't it be cooler if it was all in Hell?"
Or "Fiddler on the Roof would be so much better if weren't about Jews!"

Why does no one think these things? Because they're ludicrous!

Please, please stop it. I'm walking out of the next one. Or throwing something. Maybe a Complete Works.

5 comments:

  1. I was never much of a thespian, more of the labor-minded type: at one point I wound up building a set for A Midsummer Night's Dream, adapted to take place in the drug-induced psychedelia of the late 60's early 70's. The cast wore bells and denim vests and headbands and etc. One of my duties as set manager was to lower a mirror ball during the final scene.

    I remember watching the shameless bastardization of such a great thing from my catwalk high above the proscenium arch. I wanted to fill the mirror ball with vomit. And wasps. And drop it on Puck's head.

    You speak truth, Jimmy. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oh, Joe. You would have wanted to scratch out your eyes. Seriously, I was writhing. And since I'm hyper aware of the writing of plays, my gag reflex was on overdrive every time they'd rush through a line so they could make some visual gag.

    I have nightmares about this play.

    I'm going to see A Midsummer Night's Dream next month. I'll tell you how it goes. Crossing my fingers for no disco balls.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have come to the conclusion of 97 percent of everything is crap. Pick a category of stuff and 97 percent of it is worthless. Our lifes are just full of sifting. We are winnowers.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This made me think of this...

    http://www.theonion.com/content/news/unconventional_director_sets

    I should have discovered your blog long ago.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Jeff!

    I know you have a thousand blogs for everything you want to write about but I think you should start one and put it all there. Someone as talented as you needs his thoughts to be shared more.

    ReplyDelete

I like comments. They make me less dead inside.